svybski
Joined : 31 Jul 2007
Posts : 59
| |
Kiskun
Age : 21
Joined : 20 May 2007
Posts : 319
Localisation : Hungary, Kecskemét
|  Subject: Re: N-russians = finnougric relatives?  Wed Jan 23, 2008 3:49 pm | |
| | telkola wrote: | http://ajhg.org/AJHG/abstract/S0002-9297(07)00025-0
N-russians = finnougric relatives, south-russians other ppl ? |
The page doesn't appear.
But I have also thought about this.
Their grammar is different from the other Slavic languages, some parts are like in Finno-Ugrian languages.
And from a Hungarian perspective, Finns look exactly the same as Russians. |
|
svybski
Joined : 31 Jul 2007
Posts : 59
| | Subject: Re: N-russians = finnougric relatives? Thu Jan 24, 2008 5:07 am | |
| | Kiskun wrote: | | telkola wrote: | http://ajhg.org/AJHG/abstract/S0002-9297(07)00025-0
N-russians = finnougric relatives, south-russians other ppl ? |
The page doesn't appear.
But I have also thought about this.
Their grammar is different from the other Slavic languages, some parts are like in Finno-Ugrian languages.
And from a Hungarian perspective, Finns look exactly the same as Russians. |
The link was broken, dont click but copy-paste this: http://ajhg.org/AJHG/abstract/S0002-9297(07)00025-0
(there is parenthesis in the link and it meshes the wiki..)
Yes we do look the same  but when I read this abstract I realized that it makes sense that there are actually *2* russian people... we still are not so close relatives to S-russians
And what about east-russia? they are like half chinese half russians now.. and kaliningradians is like german/russian/polish mixture |
|
Kiskun
Age : 21
Joined : 20 May 2007
Posts : 319
Localisation : Hungary, Kecskemét
| | Subject: Re: N-russians = finnougric relatives? Fri Jan 25, 2008 6:21 pm | |
| Thank you.
So then you are Russian? |
|
svybski
Joined : 31 Jul 2007
Posts : 59
| | Subject: n-russians are finnougric Wed Jan 30, 2008 6:21 pm | |
| | Kiskun wrote: | Thank you.
So then you are Russian? |
lol  more like n-russians are finnougric.
there is vastly historical evidence of vikings (swedish, norwegians) and finns living in besides/near/along volga river.
in fact, the southernmost finnish/karelian region is in Russia east from Estonia and was independent some years sometime 1917-1921. small Finnish troop protected the area consisting of 3 villages but the agreement was Russia forced to evacuate the whole civilian population & troops in the 20s.
thousands years ago during the viking era there was lots of viking population there who spoke in vikingian language which resembles swedish/norwegian and also finnish/estonian (i think it is called ancient/old norse), which is funny.
in Siberia, and near moscow etc. there are still lots of finnougric people.
those are not necessarily very close relatives to finnish/estonians.
so I think it is no wonder that n-russians are genetically close to finnougrians since they kind of got to assimilated to the russian population... afterall the language and culture binds people, not so much your ancestors.
in fact I strongly doubt that there even is such a thing as russian people, they are more like mixture of every kind of people in the area (there are >300 different people), as the americans (u.s.) are mixture of races. (only thing what bind the americans is the flag!!)
(in fact according to one research, also finns are mixture of 2 genetically different people: let's call them "easterners" and "westerners". My guess is that westerners' ancestors were vikings (???) and easterners' ancestors were finnougric, but you cannot be sure... these two people are not totally mixed even today, i can see that there are physical (=genetical) differences: the faces of easterners and westerners look different) |
|
Kiskun
Age : 21
Joined : 20 May 2007
Posts : 319
Localisation : Hungary, Kecskemét
| | Subject: Re: N-russians = finnougric relatives? Wed Jan 30, 2008 7:33 pm | |
| | telkola wrote: | | Kiskun wrote: | Thank you.
So then you are Russian? |
lol more like n-russians are finnougric.
there is vastly historical evidence of vikings (swedish, norwegians) and finns living in besides/near/along volga river.
in fact, the southernmost finnish/karelian region is in Russia east from Estonia and was independent some years sometime 1917-1921. small Finnish troop protected the area consisting of 3 villages but the agreement was Russia forced to evacuate the whole civilian population & troops in the 20s.
thousands years ago during the viking era there was lots of viking population there who spoke in vikingian language which resembles swedish/norwegian and also finnish/estonian (i think it is called ancient/old norse), which is funny.
in Siberia, and near moscow etc. there are still lots of finnougric people.
those are not necessarily very close relatives to finnish/estonians.
so I think it is no wonder that n-russians are genetically close to finnougrians since they kind of got to assimilated to the russian population... afterall the language and culture binds people, not so much your ancestors.
in fact I strongly doubt that there even is such a thing as russian people, they are more like mixture of every kind of people in the area (there are >300 different people), as the americans (u.s.) are mixture of races. (only thing what bind the americans is the flag!!)
(in fact according to one research, also finns are mixture of 2 genetically different people: let's call them "easterners" and "westerners". My guess is that westerners' ancestors were vikings (???) and easterners' ancestors were finnougric, but you cannot be sure... these two people are not totally mixed even today, i can see that there are physical (=genetical) differences: the faces of easterners and westerners look different) |
Yeah, I read about it too. Moreover they also say there is behaviour-difference between Western and Eastern Finns. The latter are not so quiet and more loud - so they say.
But my original question is: what is your native language and where do you live? |
|
